Custom Engagement Rings New York
Your Vision, Our Experience, One-Of-A-Kind Designs
A custom engagement ring captures your unique love story in a way no mass-produced piece ever could. In the bustling heart of New York, where individuality thrives, the perfect symbol of your commitment should be as distinctive as your relationship.
At Finer Custom Jewelry, we transform your vision into an exquisite custom engagement ring that embodies your personal journey together.
The Personal Statement of a Custom-Designed Ring
Every love story deserves to be celebrated in a way that’s as unique as the couple themselves. A custom engagement ring speaks volumes about your relationship and the thought you’ve put into this significant milestone. Whether you’re drawn to classic elegance with a personal twist or seeking something completely revolutionary, a custom-designed ring allows you to create a piece that resonates with your shared values and aesthetic preferences.
Many of our New York clients come to us with stories of how they met, meaningful symbols from their relationship, or family heirlooms they wish to incorporate into their design. These personal elements transform a beautiful piece of jewelry into a wearable representation of your love story that will be cherished for generations.


Shimon did a phenomenal job finding the perfect unique stone including similar stone options so we felt confident in our choice. It was such a fun process exploring our options and designing the perfect ring. Shimon is truly a master of his craft!
I called finer custom jewelry to find a diamond ring to Propose my girlfriend and Shimon was really helpful and profesional.
Really recommend.
She said yessssss 😊
If you want to design your own piece or buy one, Finer Jewelry is the place to go!
Why Choose a Custom Engagement Ring in New York?
New York City has long been a global epicenter for fine jewelry design and craftsmanship. The city’s rich history of jewelry making, combined with its diverse influences, creates the perfect environment for creating something truly extraordinary. When you choose a custom engagement ring in NY, you’re not just purchasing jewelry – you’re investing in a masterpiece that tells your unique story.
Custom engagement rings offer benefits that mass-produced options simply cannot match:
- Complete creative control over every design element
- Superior craftsmanship and attention to detail
- The ability to incorporate personal symbolism and meaning
- Exceptional quality and value for your investment


Popular Custom Engagement Ring Styles in New York
New York seamlessly blends innovation with timeless elegance, and this spirit shines through in custom engagement rings. Couples in the city often choose modern minimalist designs with clean, architectural lines, vintage-inspired styles that echo Art Deco and other historic eras, or non-traditional rings featuring colorful gemstones, mixed metals, and personalized engravings. Each ring becomes a unique creation that captures both the couple’s love story and the vibrant energy of New York City.
GIA-Certified Diamonds vs. Lab-Grown Options
When selecting a diamond for your custom engagement ring, you have two excellent options.
Natural diamonds certified by the Gemological Institute of America (GIA) offer the allure of a stone formed over billions of years deep within the Earth. Each GIA certificate confirms your diamond’s exact specifications – cut, color, clarity, and carat weight – ensuring you receive precisely what you pay for.
Alternatively, lab-grown diamonds provide an eco-conscious choice with identical physical, chemical, and optical properties to natural diamonds. These stones are created in controlled environments that replicate the natural diamond-growing process, resulting in real diamonds that often offer better value for size. Many of our environmentally conscious New York clients appreciate this sustainable option.
Regardless of which type you choose, we source only high-quality diamonds that meet our strict standards for brilliance and beauty.


Precious Metals for Your Custom Ring
The metal you choose for your engagement ring affects both its appearance and durability. We offer several premium options:
- Platinum: Naturally white with a subtle luster, extremely durable and hypoallergenic
- White Gold: Classic appearance similar to platinum, available in different purity levels (14k, 18k)
- Yellow Gold: Timeless and warm, experiencing a resurgence in popularity
- Rose Gold: Romantic pink hue created by mixing gold with copper
- Mixed Metals: Combining different metals for a unique, contemporary look
All our metals are responsibly sourced, and we prioritize recycled materials whenever possible to minimize environmental impact – a value many of our New York clients share.
Visit Our New York Custom Jewelry Studio
While our main design studio is located in Scottsdale, Arizona, we proudly serve our New York clients through a combination of virtual consultations and strategic visits. Our team makes regular trips to New York City to meet with clients in person, and we offer comprehensive remote design services that allow us to create your perfect custom engagement ring regardless of distance.
For those who prefer in-person meetings, we can arrange appointments during our scheduled New York visits, or welcome you to our Scottsdale studio if you’re planning to be in the area. Many clients find that a combination of virtual and in-person consultations provides the ideal balance of convenience and personal connection.
Schedule a virtual consultation through our secure video platform, where you can share inspirations, ask questions, and begin exploring design options from anywhere in New York. Our design team uses advanced visualization technology to help you see potential designs in remarkable detail, even remotely.

Finest Selection of Diamonds and Gems
Our experts will provide you with the knowledge you need to make the best stone choice for idea and budget.
Between this meeting and the one after it, our design team will create a virtual mock-up, keeping you in the loop the whole way through.

Attention To Detail and Patience
We take the design and create a wax model, the exact mold used to cast your custom jewelry piece
so you can see how all the details will come together. Once you have approved the cast design, the ring moves onto its final production!

This is our favorite visit, Reveal Day!
Your jewelry will be packaged in a luxurious box and ready for gifting.
Our Client Stories


The true measure of our work lies in the joy it brings to our clients. We’ve had the privilege of creating meaningful custom engagement rings for countless New York couples, each with their own unique story and vision.
Sarah and Michael came to us,
wanting to incorporate elements from their first date at the Metropolitan Museum of Art. We designed a ring inspired by the geometric patterns in their favorite Art Deco exhibit, using a cushion-cut diamond surrounded by caliber-cut sapphires that echoed the museum’s famous stained glass.
For James and David,
we created matching engagement bands that featured contrasting metals with hidden engravings of the coordinates where they met in Central Park. The subtle exterior design revealed intricate details visible only to them – a perfect metaphor for their relationship.
Elena wanted to surprise her girlfriend,
with a ring that honored her Brazilian heritage. We sourced a rare Paraiba tourmaline in the exact shade of blue that reminded her of the beaches where her partner grew up, setting it in a design inspired by the waves of Copacabana.